Expired for sale image

Prospecting Expired Listing Scripts

Regular readers of this blog know that we devote a lot of content to prospecting expired leads.

These expired leads are with homeowners who’ve tried-and failed-to sell their property.  Perhaps it was priced poorly.  Or, maybe the agent didn’t do enough to market the property. Or, it’s possible they withdrew the property from the MLS because their life plans changed. Whatever the reason, you know that expired were, at some point, actively engaged in trying to sell, and thus, a potential revenue opportunity for you.


Here are two of the many benefits of prospecting expired leads:

  1. Typically, a homeowner who did not sell the first time has an increased urgency to sell the second time around. That gives you a good chance to convert the lead to a listing if you stick to your expired listing scripts.
  2. Working with expired listings allows you to make significant GCI over a shorter period of time, especially when compared to working as an agent for a buyer.

prospecting expired listing leads

It’s easy to be attracted to the allure of new expired listings. Indeed, if someone’s house came off the MLS yesterday, it’s possible they are frustrated or discouraged by the experience they just had. That’s why it’s so important to try and be the first agent to connect with these homeowners.

To achieve speed and effectiveness in your marketing, it is crucial to have a proven and reliable marketing plan. This plan will serve as a guide in your conversations with sellers, helping you navigate toward the successful closure of deals. One effective strategy to pursue is to utilize a tried-and-tested script for calling expired listings as part of your lead generation efforts. By doing so, you can optimize your chances of success and maximize your lead generation approach.


OK, so we get the value of new expireds. But what about those old expireds? Some might dismiss old expireds as yesterday’s news.

Well, we’re here to say: don’t be too quick to judge old expired listings as anything less than an opportunity worth pursuing with strong determination.

For the record, old expired listings could be homes that came off the MLS a month ago, or a year ago, or even longer. You need to define “old” based on the dynamics in your market. In a large market, with lots of expired listings, you might want to focus on those listings that came off the MLS one or two months ago. In smaller markets, you might want to expand your pool with much older expireds.

Two things make old expireds particularly interesting.

  • First, because many agents dismiss old expireds, you might find there is less competition when trying to build a relationship with these homeowners.
  • And, related, compared to new expired listings, those old expired homeowners are likely not being inundated with calls from aggressive agents. This gives you a unique opportunity to forge a relationship.

If you’re a Vulcan 7 client, you have access to the best old expired listings and expired listing phone numbers in the business, so you’re already at an advantage over other agents.

The next question is: what do you say?

Planning your conversation is key. Knowing the market and having the right strategy will make all the difference.


When calling an old expired listing, you want to use scripts for expired listings to learn several things:

  • Confirm that their home was previously listed and came off the MLS at a certain date. This tells them you’ve done your homework.
  • Determine if they might still be interested in selling. A key question here is: if you sold, what would you do next/where would you go?  Their future plans will give you a hint of their urgency with regard to selling their current property.
  • If they are interested, try to determine if they have an existing relationship with an agent. It’s likely they don’t have an existing relationship. But if they say “yes,” you can politely probe about the nature of the relationship to determine if you have a chance to get in the game.
  • Try to get a meeting to examine the property and begin to build a relationship.

prospecting expired listing leads

Once you’ve gotten to this point in the process by using the best expired listing scripts available, you can begin to use the other tools you have for working with expired listings.  Understanding how to maximize the value of expired listing leads is critical to success in the real estate industry.  Just don’t forget: there can be gold in those older expireds.

Contact Vulcan7 today to get started!

Doug Spak has over four decades of experience as an advertising copywriter, agency creative director, blogger, and content creator. He joined Vulcan7 as a Content Specialist in 2016. In addition to ongoing website copy refreshes, Doug has produced over 300 blog posts while developing content for Vulcan7’s social media platforms.

Ready to Get Started?

Share the Secrets

Still Have Questions Or Interested In Learning More? Contact Us Today

  • By continuing I give express permission to Kai Data, LLC/Vulcan7® to call, email, and text me. We keep your personal information safe.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Top Producing Agents Do These Five Things Regularly

What does it take to be a top-producing agent? Our…

Read More

Overcoming Call Reluctance in Real Estate Prospecting: Strategies for Success

One of, if not THE biggest, barrier to success in…

Read More

Tips for Success with FSBOs

Anyone who’s been in real estate sales for any time…

Read More